From the seller:
For details as to how this item received the given rating, see below:
The charging dock for up to 4 joy con controllers is a great accessory. It saves you the space and having to fumble between the controllers to charge them. The dock comes with a USB-C cable that can connect from the back of the switch dock to the charging dock.
It has a switch on the front to turn the lights (and charging) on or off. The controllers sit nicely and charge with no issues. The only down side is that you cannot charge and have the lights off at the same time. Personally, the lights and energy leech is an inconvenience.
There are others docks from other vendors that allow you to charge while the lights are off. If this doesn't bother you, then this charger does what is intended. The port for a pro controller was not tested, only the joy con controllers.
The plastic packaging and bags don't state if they can be recycled. Standard uncolored cardboard packaging would have sufficed.
*Note, there are two ratings applied to the reviewed item. "Product rating" and "Packaging rating". The actual product will not be impacted by the packaging as these are two separate ratings.
In regards to packaging, the following are contributing factors against the "Packaging rating":
For additional details, see below: